Skip to content

Why CRMs Fail the Buy-side

Generic CRM platforms were not built for the regulatory, operational and relationship-centred realities of buy-side firms. This paper explains why adoption stays low and data quality poor, and what wealth managers, investment managers and private banks should look for instead.

By Thakin Limited

Key takeaways

  • Generic CRMs were designed for sales pipelines, not for regulated, relationship-led buy-side businesses.
  • Buy-side professionals report low adoption, slow systems and rigid processes in the two leading CRM tools.
  • Expensive customisation rarely closes the gap.
  • Firms should choose platforms that mirror real client and investment structures, reduce admin, and treat compliance as foundational.

1. Executive summary

Customer Relationship Management (CRM) platforms were not designed with the regulatory, operational and relationship-centred realities of buy-side firms in mind. As a result, adoption remains low, data quality is poor and value goes unrealised.

This paper outlines the structural reasons CRM projects fail in buy-side environments and presents Mariner CRM as a purpose-built alternative, aligned to buy-side workflows, compliance obligations and data structures.

2. What were CRMs originally designed to do?

Traditional CRM systems were conceived to:

  • Store basic client and prospect information
  • Track sales leads and pipeline stages
  • Record interactions and activities

Today's CRMs are not tailored to the specific regulatory and operational needs of the buy-side. Under-capture, disorganisation and under-use of client and prospect data are common. Even when these systems are customised at great expense, many still fall short of what buy-side professionals need.

3. How have generic CRMs failed the buy-side?

Buy-side professionals we interviewed described their current CRM systems as challenging to use. They reported several barriers with the two major CRM tools on the market:

"If my team did not 'cajole' the salespeople, they would not use the CRM."

"Using the CRM feels like 'fighting with the machine'. It is slow, there are lots of problems, and there is little tech support."

"Current CRMs are clunky; they're these 'be all, end all' systems, but the basic functions are not working, and many of the features are 'overkill'."

"The sales opportunity pipeline needs to be constantly scrubbed to remove the 'white noise'."

"The CRM processes are too strict; there is no flexibility in the system."

"It's not built for client-facing professionals. It's built for middle managers, and it's not suited to a regulatory environment."

"Salespeople do not want to spend too much time learning how to use the system."

4. How does Mariner CRM solve these problems?

Designed by buy-side practitioners for buy-side practitioners, Mariner CRM was created for strict regulatory landscapes and industry-specific workflows. Its core design principles include:

  • An explicit buy-side data model
  • Tailored interfaces for different client-facing roles
  • Dynamic dashboards with role-specific KPIs
  • Role-based access and data segregation by firm
  • Robust audit trails and version histories

5. What should buy-side firms do next?

CRM systems only deliver value when they accurately reflect how professionals work. Buy-side firms should prioritise platforms that:

  • Mirror real-world client and investment structures
  • Reduce the administrative burden on distribution teams
  • Treat compliance and auditability as foundational, not optional

Mariner CRM addresses these requirements directly, so professionals can focus on relationships and outcomes rather than system administration.

Thakin Limited, the company behind Mariner CRM, invites buy-side firms to book a live demonstration and explore how to modernise client engagement and lifecycle management.

Book a demo

See how Mariner CRM brings your relationship information and everyday activities together.

Book a demo